Showing posts with label Investigations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Investigations. Show all posts

January 3, 2017

Eureka Math Myths

Student work from an Investigations lesson
For the past five years, I've been using the Investigations Math curriculum, both in first grade and in fourth.  So when my school district announced this year that we would be switching to Eureka math, I was a little apprehensive. Fortunately, our team was allowed to take this year to get to get familiar with new curriculum and make a gradual changeover.  As the math planner for fourth grade, it was my job to figure out to make this transition smooth.

My initial plan was to teach Investigations for the first part of the year, going at slightly accelerated pace and skipping one or two units, but mostly teaching each Investigation with fidelity. However, as I got to know Eureka more, I realized that pulling in pieces from this new curriculum early on would benefit our mathematicians. We quickly incorporated some of the fluency pieces, including "Sprints" and "Application Problems."  As we have moved further in to the year, I've included a few whole Eureka lessons, and even entire Module (unit) in between our Investigations lessons. The results have been impressive: my kiddos are doing better, faster math than they were before and they are able to explain their thinking more clearly -- both verbally and visually!

Student work from a Eureka Math Problem Set
I've heard a lot of criticism about Eureka, especially about the level of rigor it demands, but from the training I've received and my own experiences, I think a lot of it is unsubstantiated.  Eureka is definitely an accelerated program compared to Investigations (and most math other curricula I'm familiar with), but this is a result of the curriculum's tight alignment to the Common Core standards (read more about this here: http://www.edreports.org/math/reports/series/eureka-math.html).  While I have had had to go back to second- and third-grade lessons to fill in gaps and meet the current understanding of my fourth graders, I've still found that the majority of my kiddos have been thriving with the structure of the Eureka lessons and the methods of instruction. Of course, it's hard to know whether they would have been prepared for the level of math was have undertaken this year without the strong background that I believe they acquired from Investigations in Kindergarten-3rd grade, but nevertheless, I think that Eureka has some really smart ways of teaching number concepts that will benefit all young mathematicians.

So, what are the myths about this new curricula?  How does it really play out in my classroom?
Here we go:

 (Disclaimer: This is just my understanding from the instructors I've spoken to and my own interpretations of what I've read.)

Myth #1: It's a script.

As the professional developer who led my first training about Eureka put it: "If you try to follow the Eureka Teacher's Guide like a script, you'll find that your students have not been studying their lines."  Just like other curricula, the Eureka Teacher's Guide provides a sample conversation between a teacher and students -- the text is not intended to be the exact or only words that teachers use when explaining concepts to students. The dialogue can be a guide for how to explain new concepts and the types of questions to ask, but may include more language than needed or may not be sufficient for any given lesson.


Myth #2: You have to do every part of every lesson / assessment.

The Eureka Math lessons are packed -- most include multiple fluency exercises, sample problems, and discussion questions. There are also times associated with each component of the lesson. Just like with the "script," most of these components are suggested to support the skills and strategies that are being taught in the lesson/module. According to the professional developers and planners I've talked with, the times are guidelines to prevent students from spending too long on any one component, rather than a mandate to fit as much as possible into one lesson.  I've also been advised that the bulk of the lesson should be in the Concept Development, with enough independent practice for students to try out new skills but not so long that they get frustrated or bored.

Even the assessments are designed to give teachers choices. Our district has been told that the Mid-Module and End-of-Module Assessments were actually designed to be used a test bank for word problems and multi-step computation problems. Teachers are encouraged to select only the problems they think will best assess their students' skill and understanding, and also to add additional basic computation or simple identification problems as needed.


Myth #3: You can't differentiate.

Yes, there is a reason that the Eureka designers laid out certain lessons the way they did and that they chose to develop concepts across grades and modules, but that doesn't mean that each class and every student will master those lessons and concepts in the same way and in the same amount of time. Of course, some differentiation will always be needed.  In fact, one of the great things about using a well-aligned curriculum is that teachers can go back to previous grades or Modules to see how skills were initially taught or practiced.  Especially in our first year of using Eureka in fourth grade, I've gone back to second- and third-grade lessons to see how concepts like fractions, standard algorithms, and place value develop. I've taught some of these earlier lessons to my whole class and others to a sub-set of students who needed more background.


Myth #4: You can't use hands-on, interactive or investigative approaches.

It's true that Eureka relies more on direct instruction than more constructivist math programs, but I've still found plenty of opportunities for my kiddos to use manipulatives and investigate concepts.  Again, sometimes these experiences are built into lessons from previous grades that can easily be brought up or revisited with older students; other times I've incorporated the manipulatives and games that I used with Investigations. If kids need to build, bundle, balance, or bisect... then by all means, they should!  Eureka does provide tools for students to visualize concepts, including individual white board templates, cut outs, place value cards, etc.. In addition, I've found that the Application Problems work really well for partners or small groups, while many of the Concept Development problems lend themselves to being "investigated" using a constructivist approach. Plus, online resources like Zearn.org can give students additional blended-learning practice with skills directly from Eureka.

So there is it ... my assessment of Eureka Math. All in all, I'm enjoying getting to know this new curriculum and seeing how it supports my kiddos' math learning.


March 20, 2016

Why Math Games?

When I first started utilizing math games (as part of the Investigations Math Curriculum), I was rather skeptical about their efficacy.  For one, it was hard to tell if my kiddos were really doing any math while they were playing with dice and cards.  Secondly, even if they were doing math, they weren't producing any "evidence" that could be checked or graded so I couldn't know if they were correct.

As I learned more about how to instruct students to communicate while playing math games, I became more confident that my kiddos were actually doing math.  I also found ways to have them record their responses, like keeping score in other games, so I could confirm that they had done the math correctly.  In addition, I became more adept in matching students to partners who could provide appropriate challenge and support while playing together.

Nevertheless, I wasn't really convinced that all math classes should include math games until I switched to a school that did not use games at all.  I was initially looking forward to trying a direct-instruction approach to teaching math. I expected that my students would be better able to comprehend difficult concepts like "counting on" when they were explicitly taught.  I also thought that management during a direct-instruction lesson would be easier.

Here's what I realized... math is challenging no matter how it is taught and, just like other skills, like reading or riding a bike, kiddos need to have lots practice doing math to really get it.  After I taught a direct-instruction lesson, I noticed that my kiddos would solve a few problems and then get bored and tired. Management became more difficult when they felt overwhelmed by a packet of worksheets.

Despite the direct instruction approach my new school was using, I started introducing a few math games to my first graders.  I realized that there were many other benefits to math games that I'd previously taken for granted. Specifically, math games are fun!  Teaching a lesson on how to "count on" was only one part of having students understand and be able to use this strategy.  Playing math games, like "Roll and Record" with a number cube and a dot cube, gave my kiddos sufficient practice thinking of a number and counting up the dots in a fun way. Unlike simply completing more worksheets, math games also provided just enough variation to keep kiddos actively thinking about the new strategy they were using.

I'm now back at my previous school, teaching a new grade, and learning new math games.  Recently, two of my kiddos came over in the middle of a debate about a math game I'd just taught them -- a decimal version of the card game War.  One kiddo said that his card (0.81) had won and the other disagreed (he had 0.9).  As I listened to each of them explain his side, I heard them using the math language I'd taught them: hundredths, tenths, decimal, and equivalent.  Before I even had a chance to weigh in, the kiddo who had insisted he'd won said, "Oh yeah! You're right: 0.9 is greater! Okay, let's keep going!" and off they went to keep playing!  I feel confident that conversations like this, where kids are teaching each other and having new realizations, would not have surfaced had they been working independently to solve the same problem on a worksheet.

January 18, 2014

Ways to Make "n"

Right before Winter Break we were in a Number System Unit in Math, focusing creating equivalent equations.  I posed questions to the kiddos such as, "I have ten toys. Some of them are blocks. Some of them are marbles. How many of each could I have?"  Our Investigations curriculum has a variety of these "how many of each?" problems throughout the first grade program.

This year my school is fortunate to have a consultant from the curriculum working with our staff, and she gave us some suggestions for how to make these lessons more meaningful and effective for our mathematicians.  First, she encouraged us to have the kiddos build all of their equivalent expressions with connecting cubes.  

In the past I'd always used two-sided counters to help students visualize different combinations, but with the connecting cubes it's much easier to see how different combinations all equal the same number.  As the kiddos constructed trains with two colors of cubes, it was also very evident how they were thinking about the problem.  Some of them quickly organized their trains with the "pairs" next to each other (i.e. 2 red + 8 blue and 8 red + 2 blue); others started with 1+9 and increased one color while decreasing the other.  Some of the kiddos just tried out various combinations to see if they added to 10. 

The second piece of advice we received was to keep the sums small.  When the kiddos started guessing equivalent equations (8+5=10?), we were encouraged to scale back to a smaller number.  Almost all of the kiddos could find equivalent expressions within 5, even when they struggled with 9 or 10.  Even when a kiddos demonstrated understanding and fluency with combinations up to 10 or 12, we didn't provide a bigger sum.  The reason being that once you realize the pattern (increase one color, or addend, while decreasing the other), you can do it with any number.  Instead, we asked kiddos to try using three addends, or colors.  This was a challenge, but most "high-flying" mathematicians love a puzzle and enjoyed giving it a try.  

One of the first things I ever pinned on Pinterest was this "__ Ways to Make __" worksheet from Kinder-Craze.  I decided it was perfect thing to add into this session to have one more way of visualizing equivalent combinations.  We actually don't do much coloring in our class, so they loved getting to pull out the crayons and create these fun designs.  (I don't have a lot of bulletin board space but they looked great on the window above our math shelf.


September 25, 2013

Ordering Numbers

I'm trying to stay caught up on blog posts, but there's so just so much that happens in the first few weeks of school!

I took these pictures two weeks ago while we were working on ordering numbers.  Here the kiddos are working to build towers of numbers and put them in order, least to greatest.  As I started to write about this activity, I realized that we've already moved so far beyond this lesson.  Today we began finding different combinations of numbers that can equal 7 (i.e. 5+2, 4+3, 6+1, etc.).


Nevertheless, I'm reminded of how essential it was that the kiddos started with these foundational activities.  We begin our year with a series of "games" where the kiddos match numerals to quantities, order quantities, determine less and greater, and count specific quantities.  Although we progressed through these lessons quickly, they really set the tone for the year: we developed common math language, identified strategies for counting and double-checking, and established the importance of counting and comparing accurately.

These first few weeks have also been a valuable time for me to gather anecdotal notes.  As the kiddos worked, I walked around taking notes about how they read numbers (do they know the difference between 6 and 9?), how they count quantities (do they start at 1 each time or can they group small amounts and count on?), and how they order and combine (do they have to count up or do they have an instinct about larger numbers?).  I have also been able to pull small groups of students who need to shore up their basic skills (I had a few kiddos who were not able to accurately draw or count a group of 20 objects.)

More to come on the math games that were introduced during this unit...




September 22, 2013

Strategies for Counting

This summer I was fortunate to attend the 5-day workshop Investigations in the Classroom workshop, hosted by my school. The training focused on how children develop number sense and mathematical reasoning skills.  We were able to explore some of the games and activities that are part of the Investigations curriculum and consider how we might adapt or extend these learning experiences to meet the needs our students.  

One of my biggest take-away from the sessions was the difference between strategies and tools.  As a math teacher, especially of young mathematicians, my hope is that my kiddos develop many strategies for solving math problems. I want them to be able to approach a problem in different ways so that, eventually, they can find the most efficient and practical way to solve it. 

However, too often, we end up teaching students to use the same strategy with a variety of tools.  For instance, students may learn to add using their fingers, cubes or counters, and by drawing pictures, but they may only use the simplistic strategy of "counting all" (starting at 1 and counting up).  Similarly, students can learn the "counting on" strategy (starting at the larger number and counting up) using their fingers, a number line, and a 100-chart.  

While tools, such as the 100-chart, are necessary and valuable for young learners; it is important to emphasize the strategies that students choose, rather than just the tool, so that the students can become critical of their choices.  I often see kiddos, especially when I'm tutoring struggling older students, who are reliant on tools, like pictures or number lines, and can not analyze a problem to choose a creative, logical, or more effective strategy to find a solution.

This year, I am trying to be very explicit with my kiddos about strategies.  I made a chart to remind us of the strategies we already know; as the year goes on, I'll add to it.  When a kiddo volunteers to share how he solved a math problem, I encourage him to name the strategy he used and then explain his tool (if any). We are currently playing a lot of games where the kiddos are combining numbers (more on these games later) so they are getting lots of practice explaining their strategies with partners as well.



May 10, 2013

The Power of 10

In first grade, I put a great deal of emphasis on learning combinations of numbers that equal ten.  When I started teaching, I didn't fully understand how important it was for young students to develop fluency with the number 10 and internalize these combinations.  It wasn't until I started tutoring 2nd graders who are behind in math, that I realized how critical it is for students to understand that not only does 5+5=10, but also 8+2 and 7+3 and 3+7.  Because we have a base ten number system, knowing these combinations is actually the foundation for understanding place value, estimation, addition, subtraction, and mental math with bigger numbers.  

Through our Investigations curriculum we have a lot of games that reinforce number combinations up to and equal to ten.  In addition to these games, I have started using transition time to review key facts.  The kiddos really enjoy when I toss a ball and call out a number between 0-10, then they gets to toss the ball back and say the number that will equal 10 (like 1 and 9 or 4 and 6).

I urge the kiddos to "put away their fingers and turn on their brains" to recall these combinations quickly.  I know that the faster and more automatically they can connect numbers to equal ten, the more comfortable they will be to add and subtract.  Once the kiddos have committed these combinations to memory, they are able to use the "get to 10" strategy for adding larger numbers.  For example, in order to quickly add 8+4, the kiddos can "get to 10" by taking 2 from the 4; then they know there are 2 left over so there are 12 all together.  Eventually, the kiddos can also use these primary combinations to add 2-digit numbers, such as 40+60.  If students know that 4+6=10, they know that 4 tens (40) plus 6 tens (60) equals 10 tens (100).

Although we practice these combinations throughout the week, we really work on building confidence and teaching mental math strategies on Fridays.  More to come on our "Fluency Friday"routines and Math Minutes!

January 29, 2013

Would you rather...

Recently, we had "survey day" in first grade!  This is one of my favorite days in our math curriculum.  Both the first and second grade students have been learning about collecting and representing information from surveys as part of our data analysis units.

In the morning, a small team of second graders visited our classroom to survey the first graders.  They were collecting data about how many teeth each first grader had lost (their answers varied from 0 to 9).   I love that the second grade survey day corresponded with ours because it makes the progression of learning very evident.  My kiddos were so excited to find out that they would get to survey other classes when they get to second grade (if they become excellent surveyors!)

In the meantime, they developed questions to ask their own classmates.  The kiddos worked in partnerships to think of a "Would you rather" question. A few of their questions were:

  • Would you rather read mystery books or fairy tales?
  • Would you rather watch a movie inside or play outside?
  • Would you rather eat strawberries or a banana?


After they had their question, each partnership had to plan out which parter would ask the question and which partner would record the responses.  They also needed to determine how they would record the responses.  I made sure that they had class lists, colored cubes, blank paper, and colored pencils available to choose from.  Many of the kids used the class list to make sure they got around to everyone in the class.  Each partnership got a chance to go around the room and asked their question (while the other kids worked on story problems in their math books).  

After the groups finished their data collection, they made representations of their information using pictures, tally marks, cube towers, or names.  They also answered questions about how many total students answered their question, which response received more responses, and what information was surprising or interesting from their survey.   This is such a fun lesson because the kiddos are very invested in accurately collecting their data and making representations. They also get to practice some important partner skills as they negotiate and compromise about the question they want to ask and how to divide up duties.  

Now the kiddos are interested in turning everything into a survey... oh boy.  

December 28, 2012

Addition v. Subtraction

A couple of weeks ago, the little guys and I started discussing strategies to solve subtraction story problems (see post).

Just as the kiddos were getting comfortable with this idea, I threw in a new twist ... addition and subtraction word problems on the same page!  In order to solve these problems, the kiddos had to determine if the problem required addition or subtraction.  For this, I really focused on visualizing and retelling the action of the story.  We also noticed that word problems often have key words that suggest either addition or subtraction. 

I knew that taking this next step would be challenging, and although I tried to make it seem like a very exciting step, some of the kiddos were still a litte wary.  In order to make things as easy as possible, I wanted to create an anchor chart that contained tips and strategies the little guys could reference as they went about tackling these problem sets.  

Here is what I came up with:


So far it has proved very helpful!  When a kiddo comes to a problem that he is not sure what to do with, I encourage him to check the chart for key words and then choose a relevant strategy.  As one of my adorable kiddos put it, pointing to the chart, "This really helps me!" As a  class, they are getting better at deciding which operation to use and choosing logical strategies.  

{from Investigations Math, 1st Grade}
Some of the kiddos have even moved on to "challenging word problems" which take a little more thought and use slightly larger numbers. They continue to reference the chart thoughtfully and are beginning to internalize the strategies that work best for them. I love math anchor charts!  

Subtraction

We have reached a milestone in first grade... starting subtraction!  Subtraction is a big deal in first grade.  The kiddos know it exists and they get the general concept, but it still seems like a bit of enigma.  Last week we finally figured it out!

Our Investigations Math curriculum has a lot of games that introduce and reinforce concepts, so we started by adapting some familiar math games from addition games to subtraction games.  The kiddos practiced counting back and using doubles and familiar number combinations to find the difference between two numbers.  Most of the kiddos were able to do this pretty easily out loud and on their fingers.

Then I introduced subtraction story problems.  The most challenging thing about subtraction seems to be remembering which strategies to use to solve a subtraction problem.  A lot of kiddos are so comfortable using addition strategies that they get themselves all confused by drawing the wrong picture or trying to count all instead of counting back.  Therefore, I spent a lot of time this past week retelling the sequence of events in subtraction story problems and modeling what happens when we subtract.  We used counters, fingers, and pictures.  Then we created an anchor chart to remind us of the subtraction strategies we know.

The kiddos have been doing a pretty good job of incorporating these strategies into their mathematical repertoire.

October 30, 2012

Geometry

More math...

Investigations has two units on geometry to first grade but this year I decided to combine them into one unit that will cover both 2D and 3D shapes.  So far the first part of the unit is going really well.  Most of my kiddos came into first with a strong knowledge of shapes.  They could name the basic shapes (circle, square, triangle) and define simple attributes about them.

Therefore, I have been working to introduce new vocabulary to describe shapes (vertices, polygons), and also challenge their thinking about what defines a shape.  On Friday, we had a great discussion regarding what defines a "quadrilateral."  I introduced the word and explained that quadrilaterals are 4-sided shapes with 4-corners, or vertices.  I asked the kiddos to name some quadrilaterals and, not surprisingly, they came up with square, rectangle, diamond (or rhombus), and trapezoid.  Then I sent them back to their seats to explore with geoboards.  As the kids were making shapes, I took some pictures and put them up on the SMART board for our discussion.

During our discussion at the end of the lesson, I asked the kids if they thought these shapes were quadrilaterals.  Although of course they are, this is a challenging concept for first graders to accept.  We talked about the characteristics of quadrilaterals and checked the shapes on the board.  The looks on the their faces when I explained that all of the shapes we'd seen were quadrilaterals were priceless!  It's so exciting to see them make this kind of mental breakthrough in their understanding.  I'm looking forward to the next part of the unit which focuses on 3D shapes because I know our discussions will continue to be lively and informative.

Investigations Math

My school uses the Investigations Math curriculum.  I was pretty hesitant about embracing Investigations last year because I had a seen some critiques of the program (such as this one from Out In Left Field), which certainly made it look like a weak program.

I have to say, though, that my kiddos frequently impress me with the depth and breath of knowledge they are developing as I work to follow the program with fidelity.  A few weeks ago we were working on solving addition word problems - a critical skill for first graders.  I love that I have a SMART board in my room because as the kiddos were working I went around and snapped a few pictures of the different strategies they were utilizing and displayed them on the board.  We had a great discussion at the end of the lesson about why some strategies work better than others and, regardless of the strategy used, why the answers should all be the same.  I think they are really learning to be fluent and flexible with numbers, while also understanding that there is a right answer that they need to reach.

This kiddo organized her pictures by making two rows.
This kiddo is using a number line to count on.


This kiddo drew pictures and then numbered as she counted all.